So, I wanted to take a look at this Napster To Go thing that I’ve seen hyped here and there recently. It turns out that it’s total fricking bullshit and there’s no way I’d give up iTunes for that.
Check this line: “It is necessary to maintain a Napster subscription in order to continue access to songs downloaded through the Napster service.”
That means that although you originally get more songs cheaper than you would on iTunes you’ll need to pay Napster for the rest of your natural life to continue to be able to play them… And it doesn’t take a genius to work out that you’re going to run out of music to download before long… and if you don’t run out of music you’ll certainly run out of hard drive space if you try to keep the total cost less than that of iTunes over time.
Let me break this down…
There is a fee of $14.95 per month for Napster To Go.
The maximum capacity of a Napster To Go enabled portable player is 5GB (as far as I can tell).
The maximum iPod capacity was 60GB last time I checked.
I, for one, have over 1000 tracks which I intend to still listen to for the forseeable future.
I could buy 5GB of songs (very roughly 1000 tracks) from Napster and download them in 2 months, giving me a cost of $29.90, not including the amount I’d have to spend on the player. It may seem like pretty good value at the moment, but presume you wanted to keep being able to play these songs for the next 10 years. You’d need to pay Napster a grand total of $1794 just to play them, your portable player would be full and you’d either have to start removing songs from it or get another player if you wanted any new songs.
If I use iTunes to get the same 1000 tracks it’d cost me $990, that’s $804 less. My iPod would potentially still have enough space for 11 times as many tracks, and I would never have to pay another cent to Apple to continue to play these songs. I could use the $804 I’d save over the 10 years to buy another 812 tracks.
Oh yes, also, iTunes gives away 2-3 free tracks every week. Not all of them are great, but there are many that I’ve liked very much so far. That’s potentially 1560 free tracks over a decade. That’s 1.5 times the total amount tracks it takes to fill a Napster To Go portable player, for free.
Of course, neither of the options I explored take into account the ability to store songs on the hard drive, or burn the tracks to CD and rip them back to avoid the copy protection. I’ll presume you wouldn’t want to break the law, or terms of service.
Anyways, that’s why I’ll never EVER sign up for Napster To Go. I certainly don’t think anyone else should either. Not unless they intend to burn all of their tracks to CD, rip them back onto their computer, and use an iPod as their portable player of choice. Even then it would cost a lot in blank CDs, and be a very time consuming process (even if you used a virtual CD drive).